When it comes to my kitchen repertoire, there are very few dishes that I actually keep in rotation. I have my go-to salad recipe, my afternoon snack (that is 10 times better than avocado toast), and a green smoothie that fuels most of my mornings. Everything else I eat is either some kind of experiment or a hodgepodge of ingredients that I have on hand and can turn into a bowl or is a result of what I’m craving that day. So, when I find a recipe that I make not only multiple times over the course of a year, but multiple times within a month, you know it’s got to be a good one. Enter my five-ingredient pesto parmesan potatoes.
We are, of course, deep into potato season, and I couldn’t be happier about that. It’s all about the fluffy mashed potatoes and caramelized sweet potatoes, but I’m here to talk about roasted potatoes. On their own, a roasted potato is pretty good. The crispy golden brown texture and buttery insides are hard to beat, but when I think about potatoes, it’s all about using them as a blank canvas. By using a handful of ingredients that are packed with flavor, these potatoes go from really good, to really freaking great.
The best part of this recipe is that you can use whatever potatoes you have on hand. I used a bunch of different varieties: Yukon golds, fingerlings, and teeny tiny baby potatoes. With a few cutting tricks, all of these will roast together on one sheet tray and be fork tender ready at the same time. For the baby potatoes, I keep them whole. You can halve them if you like, or halve a portion of them, but I like having the skin caramelize in the oven on these. For the fingerlings, I just cut these into halves by the cross-section so the inside can get crispy on the sheet tray.
And for me, the star of these potatoes is the Yukon golds. Since these are larger than the other potato varieties, not only did I halve them, but I also Hasselback sliced them so the heat could get through the potato easier and cook them at the same time as the other potatoes on the tray. Plus, this allows for the pesto topping to seep into the potato and add a ton of extra flavor.
Speaking of, let’s chat pesto. I used store-bought. Yup, all about a shortcut here. Plus, there are a lot of great pesto varieties out there nowadays that are just as good as homemade. If you make a great homemade version, more power to you, but for the sake of ease here, there’s no judgment in using what’s in the jar.
To serve, I add some caramelized and roasted garlic paste that adds a subtle sweetness, salty parmesan, and zingy lemon that helps cut through the richness of the potato and cheese. I have definitely just stood over my kitchen island and eaten these potatoes straight off the sheet tray for dinner—ain’t no shame in that game!
Whether you serve these up as a side to a Sunday roast, or on your Thanksgiving table, I guarantee these will be on repeat in your kitchen, too.